Material guide

Paper inserts vs plastic trays for custom packaging

How to compare paper inserts, plastic trays and other insert options for gift boxes, cosmetic boxes and product kits.

Inserts are easy to overlook, but they decide how the product sits inside the box. They also affect material choice, cost, assembly time and sustainability requirements.

Paper inserts are often useful when a brand wants a paper-based packaging system. Plastic trays can give precise shape control, but they may not fit every brand policy. The right choice depends on product weight, protection needs and buyer requirements.

Insert comparison

Insert type Good for Watch out for
Paperboard insert Cosmetics, candles, gift sets, light products May need testing for heavier items
Corrugated insert Shipping kits, e-commerce packs Thicker and more utilitarian
Molded pulp-style insert Natural look, protective packing discussions Shape and finish need early confirmation
Plastic tray Precise product holding May conflict with plastic reduction goals
Foam insert Fragile or premium products Check buyer policy before quoting

When paper inserts make sense

Paper inserts work well when the product is not too heavy and the brand wants to reduce plastic. They can be printed, die-cut and matched to folding cartons, mailer boxes or gift boxes.

They are common in custom cosmetic boxes, candle gift sets and promotional kits.

When stronger inserts may be needed

For glass, electronics, heavy jars or fragile premium products, protection may matter more than using one material family. In that case, send the product weight and shipping route so the supplier can suggest a practical insert.

Plan inserts before artwork

The insert affects internal dimensions. If you approve the outside box artwork first and change the insert later, the box size may need to change.

Related pages: responsible packaging, custom gift boxes, candle box inserts guide.

Request a quote

Send the basic box details. Get a practical answer back.

Share the box style, size, quantity and destination. Artwork is helpful, but not required for the first estimate. If your project has recycled paper, FSC paper, plastic-free packaging or supplier code requirements, send them before sampling.